Homosexuality as Grounds for a Marriage Annulment

Where You Need a Lawyer:

(This may not be the same place you live)

At No Cost! 

 What Are Some Common Reasons for an Annulment?

An annulment is a legal procedure that ends a marriage. Annulment laws, unlike divorce laws, effectively treat a marriage as if it never occurred.

A marriage may be annulled for a variety of reasons. Some examples are:

  1. Duress
  2. Fraud
  3. Mental illness
  4. Undisclosed prior marriage

Overview of the Annulment Process

When a marriage fails, partners may contemplate alternatives to divorce, such as legal separation or annulment.

Certain faiths may regard annulment as enticing. If your organization does not accept remarriage after divorce, an annulment may enable you to seek a lawful remarriage on both religious and civil grounds.

An important distinction between divorce and annulment is that in an annulment, the spouses are regarded as if they never married in the first place.

For example, following an annulment, your legal status on documents will be “single” rather than “divorced.”

If you have children from an annulled marriage, they will still be considered legally valid, but they may not be deemed legitimate in the eyes of your faith. This may be a key consideration when evaluating whether an annulment is appropriate for your case.

Couples seeking annulments, on the other hand, are usually not married long enough to produce children together.

A second distinction is that most states now provide a no-fault divorce, which enables a couple to end their marriage without showing that one spouse or the other committed adultery.

In contrast, if you seek a civil annulment, you must demonstrate a cause other than irreconcilable differences to justify dissolving your marriage.

After a civil annulment, you will be able to split your property the same way you would if you had gone through a traditional divorce. If you have children with your husband, the same principles that apply in divorce will apply to calculating child support and custody.

Only a civil annulment may officially terminate your relationship and all its duties. Religious annulments usually do not affect one’s position in a religious community and are not recognized by the government or other formal bodies.

What Is a Divorce?

A divorce is the formal dissolution of a marriage or domestic relationship.

There is no requirement for a particular cause to divorce, and neither party must consent. The procedure could take at least six months.

A divorce will lay out financial and estate planning issues, including spousal support, how to split assets like real estate or joint funds, and obligations like loans or other debt.

A divorce clarifies custody, visitation rights, and child support for married spouses with children.

How Have Courts Viewed Homosexuality as Grounds for an Annulment?

Courts have sometimes seen one spouse’s hidden gay behaviors or inclinations as fraudulent conduct, creating the foundation for annulment.

The timing of the action is an important component in assessing whether the marriage may be annulled.

Some courts have ruled that if homosexual behavior occurred many years before the marriage, there are no grounds for annulment.

Furthermore, as the issue of same-sex marriage becomes more national and more states begin to recognize the validity of those unions, likely, a court will no longer entertain one of the parties’ private sexual nature as grounds for annulment. Thus, arguments would be better focused on other theories.

What if I Have Legal Issues Involving an Annulment?

Only by establishing one of the following reasons may you get a civil annulment, which officially dissolves your marriage:

  1. Fraud or duress
  2. Absence of consummation
  3. Incest
  4. Bigamy
  5. Lack of consent
  6. Unsound mind
  7. Force

This implies that you will need to contact a lawyer, which may be unnecessary if you seek a no-fault divorce.

These are some instances of how you may demonstrate the required reasons for a civil annulment.

  1. One partner may be physiologically unable to produce children, and that spouse may have lied to the other spouse about it. This would imply both deception and a failure to consummate.
  2. Incest is described as a connection between two blood relatives who are not legally permitted to marry in their state.
  3. Bigamy occurs when one individual is already married when they marry someone else
  4. Lack of consent may occur when one spouse is too young to agree on their own behalf, and the other spouse does not get legal approval from the underage spouse’s parents.

If you or your spouse were under the influence of alcohol or drugs at the time of your marriage, you might be able to demonstrate an unsound mind. If you were unable to comprehend what you were doing due to drinking or a mental illness, you might be entitled to get an annulment.

Finally, if one spouse intimidated, blackmailed, or bullied the other spouse into marriage, the marriage might be invalidated.

However, if none of these factors apply to you, it may be difficult to persuade a court to grant a civil annulment. You may still be able to seek a religious annulment, but this has no bearing on your legal obligations as spouses.

Legal Separation

Though some LGBT couples may opt to live apart informally, such as by moving out of a shared house, legal separation entails a legal procedure comparable to divorce. In contrast to divorce, when a couple legally splits, they remain legally married.

A couple may pick this choice for a variety of reasons. They may, for example, have a personal or religious objection to divorce. Or they may need to keep certain marital advantages, such as pooled health insurance.

It is also possible that the couple has just relocated and does not yet fulfill the residence criteria to file for divorce.

Although the pair remains married, formal separation enables them to clarify matters such as child custody and asset and liability splits.

Myths About the Catholic Church’s Annulment Process

There are several misunderstandings regarding what the Catholic Church considers grounds for religious annulment.

One prevalent misconception is that annulment will terminate a legitimate marriage.

On the other hand, the Church does not forget about your previous marriage and allows you to start a new one just because a religious annulment was granted.

In reality, an annulment does not terminate a legitimate marriage. What it does is determine whether or not a legitimate marriage ever occurred. Even if a civil court permits your divorce, nothing, according to the Church, can sever the connection if the marriage is lawful.

A ruling that a legitimate marriage did not take place no longer ties the spouses to each other. They were never married in God’s sight.

Annulments are appealing to faithful Catholics because they allow them to remarry without the Catholic Church objecting to their second marriage.

Annulments are seldom reported in the media unless they involve a well-known Catholic politician or celebrity. An annulment is a less common process than receiving a divorce.

Should I Speak to an Attorney about Annulling My Marriage?

Annulment, separation, and divorce may all have a negative impact on your life.

Any legal procedure should be discussed with a family attorney.

An educated and empathetic attorney may make the process go much more easily. This is especially critical if your relationship includes problematic elements such as immigrant status, domestic abuse, child custody, or a convoluted distribution of assets and responsibilities.

A lawyer will guide you through the annulment procedure, assist you in selecting the best argument, and guarantee that everything is done legally and in your best interests.

Did you find this article helpful?
Not helpfulVery helpful

Save Time and Money - Speak With a Lawyer Right Away

  • Buy one 30-minute consultation call or subscribe for unlimited calls
  • Subscription includes access to unlimited consultation calls at a reduced price
  • Receive quick expert feedback or review your DIY legal documents
  • Have peace of mind without a long wait or industry standard retainer
  • Get the right guidance - Schedule a call with a lawyer today!
star-badge.png

16 people have successfully posted their cases

Find a Lawyer