How to Sue a School District in Utah

In order to sue a school district in Utah, you must have a thorough understanding about the proper procedures and laws concerning lawsuits against local governmental entities. In most cases, suing a school district will involve you as a parent suing a school on behalf of their child. However, you may also sue a school district in your own capacity.

The reason that filing a lawsuit against a school district typically involves a parent is because a child has rights or standing with a school district as a student of the district. In Utah, parents may soon have additional legal standing to sue school districts under certain circumstances. Recently, a parental rights bill (“SB 157”) was introduced at the state capitol.

SB 157 aims to protect parents’ rights and ensure children receive education in accordance with state law by holding districts accountable when their curriculum deviates from the intended standards. However, suing a private school or public school is typically a complicated process, and there are very few instances in which you actually have the right to sue a school district.

Because of this, it is imperative to understand the legal process and what will be required of you before filing your school district lawsuit. As far as the requirements for suing a school district, that will be dependent on a variety of factors, such as properly determining your cause of action.

To Sue a School District, You Need to Identify Your “Cause of Action”

In order to sue a school district in Utah, the first step is ensuring that you have a proper cause of action. In other words, you must have a basis for your lawsuit against the school district. In legal terms, a cause of action refers to a set of facts that are deemed sufficient in the eyes of the law to justify the right to sue.

There are numerous different legal causes of action that may make up the basis for a lawsuit against a school district. Examples of the most common causes of action against a school district include:

• Discrimination or Other Civil Rights Violations: Discrimination can form the basis for a lawsuit when a school district in Utah engages in “selective admissions” or denies a student admission to school based on a protected category.
  • Protected categories include gender, race, national origin, or religious beliefs;
• Child Abuse: Child abuse can form the basis of a lawsuit in Utah when a school district fails to report to the proper authorities when the district knows of a child being abused.
  • A school district may also be sued for failing to step in when a child is being abused or bullied by another student;
• Sexual Misconduct or Harassment: Sexual harassment can form the basis of a lawsuit in Utah when a school district fails to protect a child from unwanted sexual advances or conduct or other verbal or physical actions of a sexual nature;
• Personal Injuries Caused by a School Employee: Personal injury lawsuits against a school district can arise from negligent acts from school employees, such as hazardous conditions that result in a student’s injury;
• Improper Expulsion: Expulsion can form the basis of a lawsuit when a school district wrongfully expels a student. Expulsion is a form of discipline dispensed when a student engages in conduct that the school board has outlined as inappropriate, such as drug or alcohol use on campus, fighting with another student, or severely disrupting the learning environment.
  • If you believe that your child has been wrongfully expelled, you can sue the school and the school district for damages, including an order reversing the expulsion;
• Disabilities and Special Education: It is important to note that federal laws require schools to adhere to several laws and stipulations regarding disabled students and special education programs.
  • The Individuals with Disabilities Education Act provides legal rights for students, and if a school or district fails in its duties, you may have a valid legal claim against the school district;
• Failure to Return Personal Property: Failure to return personal property can form the basis of a lawsuit when a school district takes a student’s personal possessions, such as their cell phone, but fails to return the item within a specified timeframe;
• Employment Claims: In some cases, you may need to sue the school district you are employed by for claims related to your employment, such as for workers’ compensation, wrongful termination, or wage and hour claims.

It is important to note that because of governmental immunity, public schools in Utah are generally protected from certain types of lawsuits. In other words, governmental immunity shields the Utah towns and school districts from interference from civil lawsuits.

However, governmental immunity has its limitations. Governmental immunity varies from state to state, but essentially a government agency cannot claim immunity when they act with gross negligence or willful misconduct.

Important Step to Sue a School: File an Administrative Complaint Before You File a Lawsuit Against the School

In addition to determining your cause of action, most jurisdictions in Utah require you to first “exhaust” your administrative remedies and provide notice to the school district that you have a claim against. In other words, before filing your lawsuit against the school district, you must generally first file an administrative complaint.

An administrative complaint puts the school district on notice that there is a legal issue that you have identified and gives them an opportunity to resolve that legal issue without the necessity of involving the court system.

Importantly, a court may automatically dismiss your claim if you do not follow the required administrative process. This process sometimes involves short filing deadlines, which could also lead to automatic dismissal if the deadline is missed. As such, it is important to file your complaint against the school district within these specified time limits.

After being properly notified, if the school district then fails to take appropriate steps to remedy your legal issue, you may then get permission to privately sue the school district. It is important to note that you must submit your Notice of Claim to the appropriate administrative authority. A local attorney in Utah can assist you in determining the appropriate authority.

Is the Process the Same for Suing a Private School District?

The short answer is no. Unlike public schools in Utah, private schools are not protected by governmental immunity. As such, the process is not the same for suing a private school district. In fact, finding lawyers to sue a private school district is not as difficult as finding lawyers who are willing to sue a public school district due to the lack of governmental immunity.

When Should I Hire a Lawyer to Sue a School District?

As can be seen, initiating a private lawsuit against a school district is often a complicated matter. This is especially true if the school district is a public school district, which requires you to exhaust your administrative remedies prior to dealing with a private lawsuit in which you must get around the school’s governmental immunity.

As such, if you are having any issues related to you or your child involving a school district that you believe may warrant a lawsuit, it is in your best interests to consult an experienced Utah government lawyer. An experienced governmental lawyer will be able to guide you in your best course of legal action, including meeting any administrative filing deadlines. Further, an attorney will also be able to initiate a private lawsuit on your behalf and represent you in court as needed.